Pros: True to size (I ordered a 6.5 and it fits exactly as expected.) The shoes appear to be well made - no left over glue or thread anywhere. The dye is consistent throughout the shoe, no blotches. I've worn these for a few weeks now and they're holding up very well. They are of average comfort - about what you'd expect for a boot with a heel. I can wear these for a few hours without complaint. And have I mentioned they're adorable? :) I'm usually leery of things with buckles, but these don't look cheesy and don't have that cheap look I hate. I ordered brown so it goes with almost every outfit I own, which is very convenient.

Cons: No real cons I can find. They're a decent price, fit nice, wear well. If I could tell the manufacturer anything, it'd be to add some padding on the heel so I could wear them all day long, but that's what store bought insoles are for. ;)

These boots are really cute and look great but they have not held up well at all. After about 2 weeks of normal (and not daily) wear (errand running, dropping kids at school) the color has worn off the heel area of the boot. I'm disappointed since these weren't the cheap. A few weeks in and these look like an old beat up pair of shoes

I am in a wedding and these are the shoes the bride picked. They are very comfortable. I had to order them three times to get a pair that fit. I am a 8 in shoe but a 7.5 in heels because the front of my feet are narrow for heels and my feet slip forward into the toe. The heels then tend to slip off my feet. I sent them back no problem. Ordered the 7.5's and they didn't show up. Another refund no problem. Third times the charm. I ordered them again and FINALLY I got a pair that fit. The foam soul in the show is comfy and the shoes have a nice shine, so back in the box until the wedding. Shiny shoes tend to scuff.

Love these, true to size.