Don't think about it. Just do it. Buy them immediately. I wear between a 7 and a half & 8, have high arches & wide feet. I always do an 8 in boots to give room for tights & thick socks. The reviews had me worried - I went with my gut & got an 8. PERFECT FIT!!!!! Even that Amazon suggested size feature said to buy a 7 and a half - NOPE. I'm 5'6, 165 horrific lbs (post baby). My thighs & calves are average sized but that makes little difference because the leverage given by the laces fixes all of that. TOTALLY adjustable. They come to about 2 inches above the top of my kneecap. No, there's no split in the back (which I usually hate anyway because I think it makes thigh high boots look bulky, not sleek), but they DO have elastic darts on the inside about an inch away from the zipper. Perfect. They're not thigh highs if yr looking for something 3 or so inches above the knee - freak-em-boots. They ARE, however, everyday sexier-than-the-average-joe boots. They ain't Uggs, ok? ;-)
For example: "Oh! Sexy? *blush* my goodness! Why thank you! They're my fave boots, yes. Hey, cd U tell me in what aisle are the Nutella & strawberry preserves?"
Like that, Ladies. Like that. ;-)
The toe is tapered but not POINTY, nor is it rounded. It's the shape of the tip of a natural fingernail. Hope that makes sense. I have a new bunion (inherited - thanks Mom) & these boots give me zero issues with it.
As an ex-bartender, I would TOTALLY wear these for work, but if I planned on being active for hours at a time I'd slip in a gel insole or something of the like. But wldnt U do that with any heel U plan to actively wear for more than 6 hours? 0_0
The heel I measured at 3 and a half inches - stacked, sturdy, chunky but still tapered. Meaning the circumference where it meets the shoe is slightly wider than the part that meets the ground. VERY slight difference - just enough to make it NOT look like the chunk heels of the 60's &
70's (or that "Groove is in the Heart" video from the 90's). Just enough to keep it sleek & sexy...but not TOO sexy. Perfect to pair with leggings or jeans (jeggings), a regular ole bulky or slightly fitted sweater/tunic & an ornate belt...and still look like U actually put time into making it into an outfit. Or a mini sweater dress with textured tights? MERCY.
I throw these on with whatever is lying closest to me when I take my 4 yr old to preschool at the a**crack of dawn &
I'm always complimented by other moms on looking "so well put together".
I'm telling U, Ladies, theses boots are an outfit maker.
I got them in tan (not tan 15) & they are a slightly weathered look, the color of an almond shell. Or, for cosmetic folk - golden almond. And as others have stated, YEP, I'm going back for both the black and brown. TODAY.
I don't know about those other shinier "15" labeled colors so I can't vouch for them, but if U've read this entire review U've already wasted too much time in the buying process. Put em in your cart NOW & keep on movin. :)
I got them on Prime for $27. No discount, no review given for a special price, no disclaimers, none of that crap. Just real talk here.
I buy a lot of stuff on Amazon (did I mention my 4 year old Wildchild?) & this is EASILY one of the best purchases I've ever made here.
Hope this helps.
Happy shopping sisters!

Let me start off by saying I have not worn heels since my senior prom in 2011 also, I've never been able to really walk in them either. I bought these for a wedding and they are so amazing. I wear a size 7 1/2 and got a size 7. I think next time I will get a 6 1/2 because my feet are so skinny it made the heels a little difficult to keep on easily. Because of the memory foam I wore these heels for 6 hours comfortably. That was with dancing and running around all night. The heel is the perfect size not too short but not too tall. I highly reccomend these for someone who doesn't like to wear heels or isn't very good at walking in them. I bought the tan color and will definitely be getting more colors. The best part is I didn't even have to break them in they were so comfortable the very first time I wore them.

I absolutely love these boots. They look nice and fit around my calves perfectly. The only negative is that there is very little tread so I slip around on wood or tile.